EME 504
Foundations in Sustainability Systems

7.2 Centralized versus distributed and decentralized energy generation

Please watch the following video: 3:31

Module 7 video
Credit: Dutton Institute. "EME 504 Module 7." YouTube.
Click for transcript.

PRESENTER: Translating sustainability principles into actionable items is a difficult challenge for the industry, because they need to meet the standards of extended producer responsibility. In other words, it means that they have to analyze how the sustainable principles apply across the land of the supply chain. And they need to do this without compromising the quality of the product, the promptness at which it will have to be delivered.

They cannot compromise profitability, and they cannot compromise the original characteristics of the products of services. In addition to that, standards need to be applied across different processes, across different types of industries, and across cultural and geopolitical boundaries.

Interestingly enough, the greening of the supply chain has been driven by market pressures. As consumers begin to be more aware of potential risks to their health, potential risks to the health of those who are providing and producing the services and goods that they are accessing, they become more concerned about issues of fairness, about issues of trade equity, et cetera, et cetera. And they also become a lot more concerned about the degradation of the commons that occurs not only locally, but across national boundaries.

And these become even more of a challenge when you're moving the taxing of the commons from places that are very well regulated, where we understand a number of the limitations that a particular chain will have to places in developing countries that may have looser environmental regulations.

Consequently, the drivers for the industry to make these changes, to green their supply chain, are a response to attempting to maintain a customer base. They are a response to become more efficient in the use of resources.

And this is of particular interest when it comes to waste management. Because one of the major challenges that we face when we recycle is the closing of the recycling loop. And the incremental drive in using recycled goods, as opposed to virgin resources, might finally, effectively close that particular loop.

As you may imagine, there is significant overlap between the toll of principles of sustainable engineering that we covered as part of your module one and the best practices for greening the supply chain. They both come to address some of the same challenges and come from some of the same motivation. However, in this module, we are not just tackling environmental system concerns in a vacuum. We are doing an analysis that includes the economic drivers that will lead us to the use of limited environmental resources.

One of the most promising areas for distribution and/or decentralization of natural resource production is the area of energy generation. So much is this the case that two of your assigned papers deal with this subject. An important point to notice while reading these papers is that both of them address energy generation for Europe, where there is already a strong societal drive toward choosing methods of environmentally-friendly energy generation. As a consequence of this drive, papers are very positive on their outlook when it comes to implementation of distributed and decentralized energy generation to developing countries. The subject is very briefly addressed in the Alanne & Saari (2006) paper. We will discuss the potential challenges of applying distributed resource management to developing countries later. However, it is useful to keep in mind that the reasons for decentralization of resource management are very diverse.

In the paper assigned:

  • Three schematics are presented - one of a conventional centralized, one for a decentralized, and one for a distributed energy system (Figures 1-3 -Alanne & Saari 2006).
  • Semi-quantitative means to evaluate the degree of decentralization of an energy system are proposed.
  • The different kinds of systems are compared in terms of sustainability, flexibility, and reliability, among other parameters.

We are going to discuss these subjects in the class forum.

Class Discussion Forum 7:

  1. Based on the information given in the Alanne & Saari (2006) paper, create a simplified LCA for a centralized versus a distributed energy system.
  2. What differences do you think will exist between the Life-Cycle Inventory Flow Diagram energy production in Europe versus North African countries?