GEOG 479
Cyber-Geography in Geospatial Intelligence

Assignment 7 (Due at the End of Week 5)


Assignment 7 (Due at the End of Week 5)

Assume you are an online college student, watch the short video and respond to the discussion questions.

Listen to the Experts

Gary Kovacs, the CEO of the Mozilla Corporation, says it's your right to know what data is being collected about you and how it affects your online life. He recently unveiled a Firefox add-on (remember we mentioned "Collusion" last lesson?) to do just that. The current version is called "Lightbeam" if you care to download it for use with Firefox.

Three to four-year-old children spend an of average 8 hours 18 minutes a week online - from watching films to playing games - while 12 to 15-year-olds use the internet for at least 20 hours per week, according to the report, "Growing Up Digital," published in the UK in Jan 2017. (A copy of this report is in the Professional Online Library under the "Modules" tab.).

60 Minutes did an excellent overview on 9Mar2014 on the topic of the Data Brokers that will also add more context on this topic (6:40).

Wired magazine created a graphic in August 2015 that displays the amount of data a typical user will surrender when they install Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Skype, Viber, or Gmail .

Gary Kovacs: Tracking the trackers
Click here for transcript of the of the tracking the trackers video.



GARY KOVACS: I don't know why, but I'm continually amazed to think that two and a half billion of us around the world are connected to each other through the internet and that at any point in time, more than 30% of the world's population can go online to learn, to create, and to share. 

And the amount of time each of us is spending doing all of this is also continuing to grow. A recent study showed that the young generation alone is spending over eight hours a day online. As the parent of a 9-year-old girl, that number seems awfully low. 


But just as the internet has opened up the world for each and every one of us, it has also opened up each and every one of us to the world. And increasingly, the price we're being asked to pay for all of this connectedness is our privacy. 

Today, what many of us would love to believe is that the internet is a private place. It's not. And with every click of the mouse and every touch of the screen, we are like Hansel and Gretel, leaving breadcrumbs of our personal information everywhere we travel through the digital woods. 

We are leaving our birthdays, our places of residence, our interests and preferences, our relationships, our financial histories, and on and on it goes. Now, don't get me wrong. I'm not for one minute suggesting that sharing data is a bad thing. In fact, when I know the data that's being shared, and I'm asked explicitly for my consent, I want some sites to understand my habits. It helps them suggest books for me to read or movies for my family to watch or friends for us to connect with. 

But when I don't know, and when I haven't been asked, that's when the problem arises. It's a phenomenon on the internet today called behavioral tracking, and it is very big business. In fact, there's an entire industry formed around following us through the digital woods and compiling a profile on each of us. 

And when all of that data is held, they can do almost whatever they want with it. This is an area today that has very few regulations and even fewer rules. Except for some of the recent announcements here in the United States and Europe, it's an area of consumer protection that's almost entirely naked. 

So let me expose this lurking industry a little bit further. The visualization you see forming behind me is called Collusion. And it's an experimental browser add-on that you can install in your Firefox browser that helps you see where your Web data is going and who's tracking you. The red dots you see up there are sites that are behavioral tracking that I have not navigated to but are following me, the blue dots are the sites that I've actually navigated directly to, and the gray dots are sites that are also tracking me, but I have no idea who they are. 

All of them are connected, as you can see, to form a picture of me on the Web, and this is my profile. So let me go from an example to something very specific and personal. I installed Collusion on my own laptop two weeks ago, and I let it follow me around for what was a pretty typical day. 

Now, like most of you, I actually start my day going online and checking email. I then go to a news site, look for some headlines, and in this particular case, I happened to like one of them on the merits of music literacy in schools, and I shared it over a social network. 

Our daughter then joined us at the breakfast table, and I asked her, is there an emphasis on music literacy in your school? And she, of course, naturally, as a 9-year-old, looked at me and said quizzically, what's literacy? So I sent her online, of course, to look it up. 

Now, let me stop here. We are not even two bites into breakfast, and there are already nearly 25 sites that are tracking me. I have navigated to a total of four. So let me fast-forward through the rest of my day. I go to work. I check email. I log on to a few more social sites. I blog. I check more news reports. I share some of those news reports. I go look at some videos. Pretty typical day. In this case, actually fairly pedantic. 

And at the end of the day, as my day winds down, look at my profile. The red dots have exploded. The gray dots have grown exponentially. All in all, there's over 150 sites that are now tracking my personal information, most all of them without my consent. 

I look at this picture, and it freaks me out. This is nothing. I am being stalked across the Web. And why is this happening? Pretty simple-- it's huge business. The revenue of the top handful of companies in this space is over $39 billion today. And as adults, we are certainly not alone. 

At the same time I installed my own Collusion profile, I installed one for my daughter. And on one single Saturday morning, over two hours on the internet, here's her Collusion profile. This is a 9-year-old girl navigating to principally children's sites. I moved from this from freaked out to enraged. This is no longer me being a tech pioneer or a privacy advocate. This is me being a parent. 

Imagine in the physical world if somebody followed our children around with a camera and a notebook and recorded their every movement. I can tell you-- there isn't a person in this room that would sit idly by. We'd take action. It may not be good action, but we would take action. 

We can't sit idly by here, either. This is happening today. Privacy is not an option, and it shouldn't be the price we accept for just getting on the internet. Our voices matter, and our actions matter even more. Today, we've launched Collusion. You can download and install it in Firefox to see who is tracking you across the Web and following you through the digital woods. 

Going forward, all of our voices need to be heard because what we don't know can actually hurt us, because the memory of the internet is forever. We are being watched. It's now time for us to watch the watchers. Thank you. 

Credit: TED

Discussion Questions

Other areas of interest for this assignment: