In Yellowstone National Park in Wyoming, one of the most popular tourist attractions is a geyser known as Old Faithful." The neat thing about Old Faithful is that it spurts hot steaming water out of the ground at pretty predictable intervals – predictable enough that you can probably time your trip to Yellowstone to see Old Faithful erupt several times a day. If you don't happen to live nearby, you can always use the miracle of technology and check out the Old Faithful webcam [1].
PRESENTER: Old faithful here in Yellowstone National Park in July, getting ready for the eruption here.
[CHEERING]
Old Faithful here.
When you watch Old Faithful erupt, what you are seeing is geothermal energy in action. If we could just place a nice shiny turbine on top of the geyser's cone, whenever Old Faithful erupts (about every hour and a half or so), the force of the steam would spin the turbine, generating a nice flood of low-carbon electricity.
No one seriously talks about generating power from Old Faithful, but the heat beneath the surface of the earth could provide a gigantic store of energy – if only we could get at it at some reasonable cost. There are a few places, like California, Alaska, and Iceland, where geothermal energy is used to generate a lot of electricity (in Iceland's case, basically enough for the whole country). There are a lot more places where engineers are hoping that we could generate even more electricity from geothermal energy, using techniques collectively known as "enhanced geothermal."
In this section, we'll talk about how geothermal energy works and where it is currently used. We'll also talk about the potential, and some possible pitfalls, from enhanced geothermal. One really intriguing idea that we won't talk about in this section is using heat in the very shallow surface (maybe as little as fifteen feet below ground) to heat and cool your home. This idea, called "ground-source heat pumps" or "ground source heat exchange" is growing in popularity for new home construction and has the potential to save a lot of energy in buildings. But we'll wait for that until we talk about energy conservation. Here we'll stick to producing electricity directly from the heat deep within the earth's surface.
Remember how your basic steam turbine works in a power plant that uses fossil fuels: Fuel is burned to heat water in a boiler, to create steam. The steam is used to drive a turbine, which generates electricity. What if you could get all that steam without burning a single ounce of coal, oil or natural gas? That is the appeal of geothermal electricity production. In certain locations (primarily near active or recently active volcanoes) there are very hot rocks deep under the earth’s surface. In these "geothermal" regions, the temperature may rise by 40-50°C every kilometer of depth, so just 3 km, the temperature could be 120 to 150°C, well above the boiling point for water. The rocks in these regions will typically have pore spaces filled with water, and the water may still be in the form of liquid water since the pressure is so high down there (in some very hot areas, the water is actually in the form of steam trapped in the rocks). If you drill a deep well into one of these "geothermal reservoirs", the water will rise up and as it approaches the surface, the pressure decreases and it turns to steam. This steam can then be used to drive a turbine that is attached to a generator to make electricity. In some regards, this is very much like a coal or natural gas electrical plant, except that with geothermal, no fossil fuels are burned, which means no carbon emissions.
There are three basic types of geothermal power plants, depending on the type of hydrothermal reservoir:
The oldest geothermal plant (1904) in the world is Lardarello, in Italy, which is a dry steam plant. The Geysers, in California, is the largest geothermal installation in the world and the only accessible dry-steam area in the United States (other than Old Faithful and the rest of Yellowstone, which is off-limits). Most modern geothermal plants are “closed-loop” systems, which means that the water (or steam) brought up from the surface is re-injected back into the earth, as shown in the figure below. If the water is not replaced, then eventually, the geothermal reservoir will dry up and cease function.
On a global scale, the potential for geothermal energy is quite large. The IPCC estimates that even though just a fraction of the total heat within the Earth can be used to generate geothermal power, we could nevertheless generate about 90 EJ of energy per year, and this is energy that is constantly renewed from within the Earth. Keep in mind that at present, we generate just over 2 EJ per year, so this energy source can definitely expand, but by itself it cannot meet the total global energy demand of 600 EJ.
To harness geothermal energy to generate electricity using any conventional technology (dry steam, flash steam or binary steam), you’ve got to be in the right place, where there is just the right amount of hot fluid or steam in an accessible reservoir. Unfortunately, those places are few and far between. The figure below shows a map of geothermal resources in the U.S., with identified conventional sites marked with dots on the map. All are located in just a handful of western states, plus Alaska.
The state of Alaska is known more for oil and gas than for renewable energy resources, but the remote nature of many Alaskan communities calls for different energy solutions that we might use in a more connected part of the world. This video shows how some remote areas of Alaska are using locally-sourced renewable energy to power their communities, rather than relying so much on crude oil that makes up much of the state's economic bounty.
Narrator: Sometimes when Americans hear energy, the next word that comes to mind is crisis. It really doesn't have to be that way. Shirley Jackson, former head of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, and now president of one of America's leading technical universities, thinks the United States is actually well-placed. Well, the U.S. is lucky because we have such a diversity of climates and diversity of geologies and in the end, diversity of actual energy sources. And that, in fact, makes us very fortunate compared to other parts of the world. They may have a given source of energy, but they don't have the multiple sources.
Narrator: Alaska, like the rest of America, has been addicted to oil. Now, can abundant sustainable options make it America's renewable state? Kodiak Island, Alaska at 3,600 square miles is about half the size of New Jersey. Getting around almost always involves a boat, or a plane, or a float-plane that's a bit of both. Kodiak's population is less than 14,000, leaving most of the island undeveloped and natural. That beauty is one of Kodiak's economic assets, bringing tourists to watch bears raising cubs and catching fish. Kodiak's human population also catches salmon, with fish exports providing another key source of jobs and income. The island wants to limit imports of dirty and expensive fossil fuels, and tap natural resources to supply as much clean and locally generated energy as possible. Fuel prices, because we live on an island, are very expensive. You know, you learn pretty quickly that you need an alternative.
Narrator: Kodiak was the first place in Alaska to make wind power a substantial part of the energy mix, with its three 1.5 megawatt turbines on Pillar Mountain. So getting good quality, low-cost sustainable power is really necessary for the long-term viability of the economy of Alaska.
Narrator: Upgrades at the Terror Lake hydroelectric plant, plus plans for three more turbines leave the KEA co-op confident they can hit 95% renewables by 2020. Though Kodiak uses diesel as a backup and during repairs, the wind turbines save the island 800,000 gallons of expensive, imported fuel each year. And this matters to the local business community. This morning, we're offloading pink salmon and red salmon, chum salmon and coho that came from the west side of Kodiak-- it keeps us busy, the plants work 24 hours a day, and it's a very, very big industry for Kodiak.
Narrator: This processing plant runs 100% on renewable energy, so Kodiak's wind power provides a clean, green marketing hook. The package says sustainable seafood, produced in Kodiak, Alaska, with wind-generated renewable energy. You got some folks in the community that are really concerned about price. You know, they just want the lowest cost power at their house or at their business. The wind does that. It's less than 50% of the cost of power versus diesel. Then you got folks in the town that are very just, environmentally concerned. And they are incredibly excited because it's a whole lot cleaner than diesel is. And then you've got the majority of folks who want both, which is great as well.
Narrator: Kodiak is a genuine island, surrounded by ocean, but vast areas of interior Alaska are also islands of habitation, small communities surrounded by open country and dense forests. Many have no road access, and the only way to transport heavy fuel is via rivers like the Yukon. Bear Ketzler is city manager of Tanana, a remote and mainly native Alaskan village at the confluence of the Yukon and Tanana Rivers. 90% of our bulk freight that comes in, comes by the barge.
Narrator: That includes diesel for the power plant and heating oil for homes. Diesel prices increased 83% between 2000 and 2005, and utility costs can sometimes be more than 1/3 of a household's income. The increase of energy costs, it jeopardizes everything. It jeopardizes our school, it really jeopardizes the ability for the city to function effectively.
Narrator: Communities like Tanana rely on the river for the fish protein that's a large part of a subsistence diet. And the river also provides a cheap and local source of energy. We have abundant resources of wood, biomass. Wood that floats down the river, in the spring and the fall time.
Narrator: Timber is increasingly replacing oil and diesel in Tanana's communal buildings, like the washeteria, a combination laundromat, public showers and water treatment plant. Right now, we don't even need oil, we're just running the whole place off this one wood boiler, which is just amazing.
Narrator: Using biomass and solar, the washeteria now uses only one quarter as much heating oil. Instead, the city pays residents to gather sustainable timber, keeping dollars in the local community. And using biomass at the washeteria has proven so cost effective that the city is planning to install boilers in other public buildings.
Bear: We're going to be one of the first communities on Yukon River that is installing a biomass systems on the school. In October of this year we're hoping to have that wood system on line, so instead of burning 15,000 gallons of oil throughout this winter, we're hoping to burn about 60 cords of wood. And keep that money local and create a little bit of an economy here.
Narrator: The bottom line for Tanana-- savings for the city. Biomass is cheaper, local, cleaner and more sustainable.
Bear: Even though we are a very rich state, very blessed to have the oil development that we do have, those days are diminishing. If we're going to make it in rural Alaska, we have to move towards renewable resources. I think we have, you know, less than 10 years to move in that area.
Narrator: Winter in Alaska presents extreme challenges. On this January day it was close to minus 50. Gwen Holdmann is an engineer with the University of Alaska's Center for Energy and Power. She and her husband also raise sled dogs and both are mushers who have raced in the Iditarod. Today's run takes her past the Alaska pipeline, which has transported more than 16 billion barrels of oil since it opened in 1977. Despite the fact that Alaska is rich in fossil fuels, Gwen knows they're limited and expensive. She wants to take advantage of every opportunity to tap renewable energy.
Gwen: We are an isolated part of the world, and we are still dependent very much on imports, and so becoming more self-reliant on energy is still a real goal here.
Narrator: Gwen was part of the team that built the first geothermal power plant in Alaska at Chena hot springs. Bernie Karl runs the Chena Resort and came up with the idea of creating an ice museum from the heat energy of the springs.
Bernie: Now you've heard of the great wall of China. This is the great wall of Chena. There's 800 tons of ice here.
Narrator: Bernie is a real American pioneer-- a showman, an entrepreneur, a tinkerer and enthusiast for recycling old machinery because it's cheaper. He and Gwen successfully transformed the hot springs into a geothermal resource that now generates power from lower temperature water than anywhere else on earth. What you're looking at is something that's impossible. I went to the world's best manufacturer of geothermal equipment and they said, "can't be done, the word can't is not in my vocabulary." It wasn't obvious at first that it could be done because these are low, really moderate temperatures for geothermal. The water that we're talking about here is about the same as a good hot cup of coffee and generating power from that isn't a trivial thing.
Narrator: Normal conditions for mid-winter Chena are 3-4 feet of snow, subzero temperatures, and only a few hours of daylight. Heating and lighting costs were staggeringly high. But now the resort runs year-round with over 90% of its electricity coming from the hot springs. Bernie's latest impossible idea is to use geothermal power to make the resort self-sufficient in food even when it's minus 50 outside.
Bernie: We have 85kw of lights in here, high-pressure sodium. We're changing it to 8.5 kw of L.E.D.s. Now, this takes 1/10th the electricity.
Narrator: For the past 6 years Chena has hosted a renewable energy fair. One keynote speaker was U.S. Senator Lisa Murkowski.
Lisa Murkowski: I'm a Republican. Republicans by definition are seemingly more conservative. What is more conservative than harnessing what is available and around us in a long-term sustainable way? We have more renewable opportunities here in Alaska than any other place in the world. We've got incredible river systems. We have 33,000 miles of coastline, the power of the tides, the power of the currents. We have biomass potential that is just beyond belief. As diverse and as big and remote and as costly as things are in Alaska, if we can demonstrate that it can be done here, think about the hope that it provides. They'll look at us and say, "Wow, if Alaska can do it, we can do this. We can take control of our energy future."
Most places do not have that right combination of an accessible large reservoir of underground heat. Instead, reservoirs are more dispersed, in geologic formations with less permeability (this naturally inhibits the flow of hot fluid towards the surface). Engineers have discovered how to alter the subsurface to create man-made reservoirs of hot water that could be tapped to produce electricity, in either a flash steam or (with higher potential) a binary steam technology configuration. The process of engineering a geothermal reservoir underground is known as “enhanced geothermal systems” or EGS. As the resource map in Figure 2 shows, EGS could be done in a lot more places than conventional geothermal. Hundreds of thousands of gigawatts of power, basically enough to run the United States several times over, could potentially be harnessed through EGS.
The US Department of Energy has a nice animation outlining how EGS works: How an Enhanced Geothermal System Works [4]. Also, check out the interactive image of the EGS on the same page to gain a deeper understanding. Note: This animation requires Flash. If you don't have Flash installed, click the link to the Text Version of the animation.
The basic idea behind EGS is to fracture hot rocks deep within the earth to create channels or networks through which water could flow. When water is injected into these networks, the heat from the rocks boils the water directly, or the now-hot water is transported to the surface where it is used to boil a working fluid, much like a binary steam plant. Fracturing of the rock occurs via “hydraulic fracturing,” under which water is injected into the rock formation at high pressures, causing the rock to fracture. This is actually very similar to the way that natural gas and oil is being extracted from shale. So we can “frack” for geothermal in much the same way that we frack for oil and gas.
Only a few countries use geothermal resources as a major source of electricity production –Iceland, El Salvador, and the Philippines all use geothermal for more than 25% of total electricity generation within those countries. New Zealand is the next (but distant) largest at 10%. Where hydrothermal resources are easy to access they have often been utilized. Trouble is, there just aren’t that many Old Faithfuls in the world.
EGS represents the most significant potential for geothermal electricity production, but other than a few small military or pilot projects, the systems have not really caught on commercially. One of the big reasons is cost – like many low-carbon electricity technologies, EGS is inexpensive to run but very costly to build. Drilling geothermal wells is much more expensive than drilling conventional oil or gas wells, so electricity prices would probably need to increase by 25% or more (relative to current averages) to make EGS a financially viable technology.
Perhaps a more serious challenge for EGS is “induced seismicity,” which is a fancy term for causing earthquakes. EGS wells that were drilled below Basel, Switzerland caused over 10,000 small tremors (less than 3.5 on the Richter scale) within just a few days following the start of the hydraulic fracturing process. In Oregon, a test EGS well is being monitored for induced seismic activity – you can see some neat real-time earthquake data at Induced Seismicity [5] (U.S. Department of Energy: Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.
Induced seismicity occurs whenever hydraulic fracturing (related to EGS or developing a natural gas well) takes place, but in most cases, the earthquakes are so small they are not felt. However, if the hydraulic fracturing occurs near pre-existing faults (which are often not visible at the surface), then larger earthquakes can and do occur, and some of these are strong enough to cause minor damage to buildings nearby.
Links
[1] http://www.nps.gov/features/yell/webcam/oldFaithfulStreaming.html
[2] https://www.energy.gov/eere/geothermal/electricity-generation
[3] https://www.nrel.gov/index.html
[4] https://energy.gov/eere/geothermal/how-enhanced-geothermal-system-works
[5] https://www.usgs.gov/programs/earthquake-hazards/earthquakes