EBF 200
Introduction to Energy and Earth Sciences Economics

 

Other Forms of Market Power

PrintPrint

Single buyer = Monopsony

In this case, a buyer has market power and tries to maximize the consumer surplus, not the producer surplus. We essentially have a monopoly in reverse, and consumer surplus is maximized by the consumer's choice of quantity purchased. Instead of looking at the producer's marginal revenue function to define the monopoly quantity and price, we instead look at the consumer's "marginal expenditure," the amount of money he has to spend to obtain one more unit of a good, which changes with his purchase decision. Once again, we have a quantity that is less than the free-market equilibrium, but in this case a price that is lower than the free market equilibrium. This is described in the following diagram:

S & D diagram. Shows how Q(m) should be where marginal expenditure and demand intersect to determine the lowest price to quantity ratio
Figure 5.4 Marginal Expenditure
Credit: B. Posner

As you can see in Figure 5.4, the “Marginal Expenditure” line has the same intercept as the marginal cost line, but double the slope.

Monopoly-Monopsony

It is possible to have a situation where there is only one buyer and one seller. In this case, the quantity sold and the price will be a function of the negotiation between the trading partners.

Duopoly

This is the case where we have two sellers. Without getting into the mathematical details, we discover that the price is lower than the monopoly price, but higher than the competitive price. The quantity is also between the two. The best outcome for the two firms would be to share the monopoly profits between them; but each side has an incentive to cheat, which results in a different equilibrium. Incentives to cheat in a collusive environment are described in Chapter 11 of the text.

Oligopoly

In this case, we are adding a few more sellers. As we add more sellers, the equilibrium moves along the demand curve towards the competitive equilibrium, as in the following diagram:

 Where markets fall on S & D diagram. From left to right along the demand line: monopoly, duopoly, oligopoly, competitive (equilibrium)
Figure 5.5 Competitive Equilibrium
Credit: B. Posner

The obvious conclusion is that the more firms in a market, the closer we get to the competitive (wealth-maximizing) solution. This is why governments generally try to stop monopolies and break market power.

Take Aways

After this lesson and the associated readings, you should be able to:

  1. define an equilibrium in a monopsony;
  2. compare a duopoly equilibrium to monopoly and competitive equilibria;
  3. understand how an oligopoly equilibrium compares to monopoly and competitive equilibria;
  4. understand what happens to the equilibrium as we add more firms.