Print
As a final step to our Nonmarket Analysis, we build a table, as shown below, to present a summary of our findings. This table is the Nonmarket Analysis Summary Framework.
Demand Side | Supply Side | Prediction | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stakeholders - SUPPORTING | Benefits from Supporting HB 1580 | Ability to Generate Nonmarket Action | Amount of Nonmarket Action | |||||
Substitutes | Aggregate | Per Capita | Effectiveness | Cost of Organizing | ||||
Numbers | Coverage | Resources | ||||||
MAREA | none | large | small | considerable (~8,000) | extensive | limited | low | moderate |
PA-SEIA | none | substantial | substantial | small (~75) | extensive | small | moderate | moderate |
Small System Owners (in PA) | TOU elec prices, sell RECs elsewhere | large | large | large (4,000) | extensive | moderate | high | little |
"Larger" System Owners (in PA) | sell RECs elsewhere | substantial | substantial | small (530) | extensive | moderate | high | little |
Solar installers | none | substantial | substantial | small (629) | complete | moderate | moderate | high |
PennFuture | other environmental issues (gas) | moderate | moderate | large | complete | large | low | high |
Ratepayers (supporting) | buy green generation | small | small | substantial | complete | huge | very high | limited |
Stakeholders - OPPOSING | Benefits from Opposing HB 1580 | Ability to Generate Nonmarket Action | Amount of Nonmarket Action | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Substitutes | Aggregate | Per Capita | Effectiveness | Cost of Organizing | ||||
Numbers | Coverage | Resources | ||||||
Pennsylvania Coal Association | other renewable energy issues | moderate | small | few (150) | extensive | huge | very low | large |
Ratepayers (opposing) | none | small | moderate | substantial | complete | huge | very high | limited |
PA Chamber of Business and Industry | other regulation issues | moderate | moderate | large | complete | huge | very low | large |
Small System Owners (not in PA) | sell RECs elsewhere | small | small | considerable (~1,300) | little | moderate | very high | limited |