EME 444
Global Energy Enterprise

Framework

PrintPrint

As a final step to our Nonmarket Analysis, we build a table, as shown below, to present a summary of our findings. This table is the Nonmarket Analysis Summary Framework. Ta da!!

ISSUE: Pass HB 1580 to Accelerate Alternative Energy Portfolio Standard Schedule for Solar
Supporting Stakeholders
  Demand Side Supply Side Prediction
Stakeholders - SUPPORTING Benefits from Supporting HB 1580 Ability to Generate Nonmarket Action Amount of Nonmarket Action
Substitutes Aggregate Per Capita Effectiveness Cost of Organizing
Numbers Coverage Resources
MAREA TOU elec prices large small considerable (~8,000) extensive limited low moderate
PA-SEIA none substantial substantial small (~75) little small moderate moderate
Small System Owners (in PA) TOU elec prices, sell RECs elsewhere large large large (4,000) complete moderate high limited
"Larger" System Owners (in PA) sell RECs elsewhere substantial substantial small (530) extensive limited high little
Solar installers none substantial substantial small (629) complete moderate moderate high
PennFuture other environmental issues (gas) moderate moderate large complete large low high
Ratepayers (supporting) buy green generation small small substantial complete huge very high limited

 

ISSUE: Pass HB 1580 to Accelerate Alternative Energy Portfolio Standard Schedule for Solar
Opposing Stakeholders
Stakeholders - OPPOSING Benefits from Opposing HB 1580 Ability to Generate Nonmarket Action Amount of Nonmarket Action
Substitutes Aggregate Per Capita Effectiveness Cost of Organizing
Numbers Coverage Resources
Pennsylvania Coal Association other renewable energy issues moderate small few (150) extensive huge very low large
Ratepayers (opposing) none small moderate substantial complete huge very high limited
PA Chamber of Business and Industry other regulation issues moderate small large complete huge very low large
Small System Owners (not in PA) sell RECs elsewhere small moderate considerable (~1,300) little moderate very high limited
"Larger" System Owners (not in PA) sell RECs elsewhere small small small (~100) little small very high limited