Penn StateNASA

Collapse of the Honey Bees


Possibly the most threatened insects on the planet are the honey bees, an organism that plays a vital role in agriculture through pollination. The first signs of trouble were noticed in the US in 2006 when beekeepers noticed losses of up to 90% of their hives. Loss of hives is not uncommon over the winter months, but the magnitude of these losses was almost unprecedented. This problem, officially termed colony collapse disorder or CCD, is accelerating in the US and has spread to other northern hemisphere countries. When a colony is struck by the collapse disorder, it loses its function. Typically, the queen and immature bees remain, but few other adult bees are left in the hive. There is no honey, and, oddly, no dead bees are found.

European honey bee carrying nectar back to the hive, with pollen attached A forager collecting pollen Honey bees on comb

Click the images above to see full-size versions and complete source information.

Since 2006, annual losses in the number of colonies averaged about 33 percent each year, with a third of that amount resulting from CCD. However, the losses got dramatically worse in 2012. In the last year, 50% or more of all hives have been lost to CCD and the situation is really precarious.

Honey bee pollination is a crucial part of agriculture, responsible for some $15 billion in produce each year with crops including a diverse array of berries, fruits, and vegetables. These crops represent about one of every three bites of food in a typical diet. Honey bees are not the only potential pollinators for most crops, but they are the most prolific and easy to manage in agriculture. The one crop that can’t pollinate without honey bees is almonds. Almonds in the US are grown almost exclusively in California and are a multi-billion a year industry. The almond industry is very hive intensive, with about 800,000 acres devoted to the crop, requiring at least two hives per acre.

Researchers are still completely stumped by the causes of CCD. There are a number of hypotheses that are actively being investigated, but at this time, no one has been isolated as the main culprit. Quite possibly, the causes are synergistic, acting in concert with one another. Here are the candidates:

  1. Varroa mites, a virus-transmitting parasite of honey bees have frequently been found in hives hit by CCD. Thus, the mites of the virus have been one of the postulated causes of the disorder. However, there are numerous other possible culprits.
  2. Pesticides, such as Coumaphos, that are used to treat bees for the Varroa mites, are damaging honey bee brains, interfering with the insect's ability to learn and remember.
  3. Herbicides and fungicides that are laced with regulators keep bees from maturing.
  4. Pathogens are common in CCD incidents and several different pathogens have been identified. However, no one pathogen has been found in a majority of cases. Possibly, the pathogens are carrying viruses and bacteria that are responsible for the disorder.
  5. The third group of causes is associated with the way the pollination industry handles honey bees. Overcrowding and bee stress are associated with transportation over large distances.
  6. Scarcity or poor quality of pollen, drought, and contaminated water are possible culprits.
  7. Cell phone towers may also be a cause. The idea is that electromagnetic fields from the towers cause bees to become disoriented so they stop seeking out food and begin swarming.
Varroa destructor mite on a honey bee host
Varroa destructor mite on a honey bee host
Credit: Wikipedia CC BY-SA 3.0 (Creative Commons)

However, new evidence is pointing to a type of pesticide called a Neonicotinoids. It is applied in really small doses and often embedded in seeds so that the plant itself kills the insects feeding on it. The problem with these pesticides is that they do not degrade rapidly, as do other varieties, and bees can carry contaminated pollen back to their hives where other bees feast on them for months. These chemicals have now been banned by the European Union.

The number of professional bee pollination services has declined over the course of the 20th century, even before the onset of CCD. The prospects are bleak for the honey bees, but it is unlikely that CCD will cause their extinction. The losses though will definitely threaten the viability of the bee pollination industry and undoubtedly the cost will be passed along to consumers in food prices.

Large truck loaded with bees
Moving spring bees from South Carolina to Maine for blueberry pollination
Credit: Wikipedia CC BY-SA 3.0 (Creative Commons)